Posted on

Diagnosis and the DSM: A Critical Review by S. Vanheule

By S. Vanheule

This booklet seriously evaluates the 5th version of the Diagnostic and Statistical handbook of psychological problems (DSM-5). via research of the background of psychiatric analysis and of the instruction manual itself, it argues that the DSM-5 has a slender biomedical method of psychological issues, and proposes a brand new contextualizing version of psychological healthiness signs.

Show description

Read or Download Diagnosis and the DSM: A Critical Review PDF

Best administration & policy books

The Governance of Genetic Information: Who Decides?

This quantity maps the parts of moral crisis within the debate in regards to the governance of genetic info, and indicates replacement moral frameworks and types of legislation so one can tell its restructuring. Genetic governance is on the center of scientific and clinical advancements, and is hooked up to worldwide exploitation, problems with commodification, commercialisation and possession, the ideas of estate and highbrow estate and issues approximately person and communal identification.

Searching for the Best Medicine: The Life and Times of a Doctor and Patient

This e-book describes the lifestyles and occasions of a physician-scientist during the last half-century. half One is set the author's fight with colon melanoma and the teachings he learnt from the adventure; half is set his lifestyles turning out to be up, the pretzel bakery, his kinfolk, being expert at Bronx technology, Columbia university, Harvard scientific university, and his clinical education on the Boston urban sanatorium and the NIH.

The Design and Conduct of Meaningful Experiments Involving Human Participants: 25 Scientific Principles

Designing and engaging in experiments concerning human members calls for a skillset varied from that wanted for statistically examining the ensuing facts. The layout and behavior of significant Experiments concerning Human members combines an advent to medical tradition and moral mores with particular experimental layout and procedural content material.

The SAGES Manual Ethics of Surgical Innovation

This article offers a complete assessment of the moral matters concerned with the improvement, evaluate, and creation of latest remedies of gastrointestinal ailments. How numerous landmark surgical strategies have been built are defined to teach the demanding situations confronted, and the moral dilemmas those innovators handled.

Extra info for Diagnosis and the DSM: A Critical Review

Sample text

In other words, the discourse diagnosed individuals are imbedded in determine the way in which they are evaluated by others, as well as how they look at themselves. For example, recent meta-analytic research shows that biomedical explanations of mental disorders reduce feelings of blame and responsibility about having psychological problems, but also significantly increase pessimism about the prognosis of a disorder, and nourish the belief that individuals with mental health problems are unpredictable and dangerous (Kvaale, Haslam, & Gottdiener, 2013).

Of the nine personality disorders tested, eight had fair to good reliability according to the Landis and Koch (1977) standard, while one (paranoid personality disorder) had poor reliability. Notwithstanding all rhetoric on the good reliability of the DSM since 1980 it was only with the DSM-5 field trials that a major test-retest reliability study was conducted with a sample size that was comparable to the 1726 patients that Spitzer and Fleiss (1974) included in their review. , 2013). Two hundred and eighty-six clinicians participated, and a total of 1466 adult patients and 616 pediatric patients were evaluated by two trained clinicians separately.

Nonetheless, it is quite obvious that the act of characterizing individuals by means of psychiatric terminology triggers a network of beliefs and societal practices; the latter is inevitable when a discourse becomes dominant and is simply taken for granted. In other words, the discourse diagnosed individuals are imbedded in determine the way in which they are evaluated by others, as well as how they look at themselves. For example, recent meta-analytic research shows that biomedical explanations of mental disorders reduce feelings of blame and responsibility about having psychological problems, but also significantly increase pessimism about the prognosis of a disorder, and nourish the belief that individuals with mental health problems are unpredictable and dangerous (Kvaale, Haslam, & Gottdiener, 2013).

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.79 of 5 – based on 33 votes