Posted on

After Harm: Medical Error and the Ethics of Forgiveness by Nancy Berlinger

By Nancy Berlinger

Clinical blunders is a number one challenge of wellbeing and fitness care within the usa. every year, extra sufferers die because of scientific errors than are killed by means of motorcar injuries, breast melanoma, or AIDS. whereas so much executive and regulatory efforts are directed towards lowering and fighting blunders, the activities that are meant to stick with the damage or demise of a sufferer are nonetheless hotly debated. in accordance with Nancy Berlinger, conversations on sufferer protection are lacking a number of very important parts: spiritual voices, traditions, and types. In After damage, Berlinger attracts on assets in theology, ethics, faith, and tradition to create a realistic and accomplished method of addressing the wishes of sufferers, households, and clinicians suffering from clinical errors. She emphasizes the significance of acknowledging fallibility, telling the reality, confronting emotions of guilt and disgrace, and supplying simply repayment. After damage provides vital human dimensions to a subject that has profound effects for sufferers and well-being care services.

Show description

Read or Download After Harm: Medical Error and the Ethics of Forgiveness PDF

Best administration & policy books

The Governance of Genetic Information: Who Decides?

This quantity maps the components of moral crisis within the debate concerning the governance of genetic details, and indicates substitute moral frameworks and types of law with the intention to tell its restructuring. Genetic governance is on the center of clinical and medical advancements, and is hooked up to international exploitation, problems with commodification, commercialisation and possession, the strategies of estate and highbrow estate and issues approximately person and communal id.

Searching for the Best Medicine: The Life and Times of a Doctor and Patient

This publication describes the lifestyles and occasions of a physician-scientist over the past half-century. half One is ready the author's fight with colon melanoma and the teachings he learnt from the adventure; half is set his existence transforming into up, the pretzel bakery, his family members, being trained at Bronx technological know-how, Columbia university, Harvard clinical tuition, and his clinical education on the Boston urban health facility and the NIH.

The Design and Conduct of Meaningful Experiments Involving Human Participants: 25 Scientific Principles

Designing and undertaking experiments concerning human contributors calls for a skillset assorted from that wanted for statistically studying the ensuing info. The layout and behavior of significant Experiments concerning Human contributors combines an creation to medical tradition and moral mores with particular experimental layout and procedural content material.

The SAGES Manual Ethics of Surgical Innovation

This article presents a entire evaluation of the moral matters concerned with the advance, assessment, and advent of latest remedies of gastrointestinal ailments. How a number of landmark surgical strategies have been constructed are defined to teach the demanding situations confronted, and the moral dilemmas those innovators handled.

Additional resources for After Harm: Medical Error and the Ethics of Forgiveness

Example text

Contrary to myth, only a tiny percentage of injured patients ever sue their doctors. S. hospitals rarely offer compensation to injured patients without legal action first being initiated, the tort system, as Carol Levine points out, is often the only option available to those patients and families who may need compensation because of the continuing medical or financial ramifications of the original mistake (Levine 2002, 241). In many American narratives about the aftermath of medical harm, the question of whether to sue is simply part of the story, forced on the narrator and the narrative by the perceived lack of alternatives to litigation, whether as a means of compensation or as a means of finding out what really happened.

In other stories written by family members, it is the treatment of the family after a patient’s death that the family views as a mistake, and even as suspicious, although whether a medical error contributed to the patient’s death cannot be confirmed. ∏ Rowe was deeply distressed by what he perceived as a ‘‘lack of empathy’’ on the part of Jesse’s doctors following the death. Their failure to contact the family, after weeks of constant contact during Jesse’s hospitalization, began to suggest guilty knowledge, as ‘‘trust died and mistrust took its place’’ (Rowe 2002, 235).

So many people calling and stopping in to see my parents, trying to understand, offering condolences and support. Mike is gone and we cannot understand what happened, the hospital has no explanation, no apology, no condolences, and no help to try and deal with the loss. ∞≥ As in so many American stories about medical mistakes, the lawsuit enters into the narrative of Roxanne Goeltz and her family as a tool of detection, a way of finding out what really happened. Like Michael Rowe and his family, Goeltz and her family interpret the hospital’s silence as possible evidence of guilty knowledge.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.77 of 5 – based on 46 votes